If you are someone who uses drilling tools for work quite often then, you would be familiar with the very common comparison of impact driver vs drill. It can get hard to choose between the two tools. You have only one project and so many tools to choose from, but you don’t know which one is the right one for the project you are working on. While drills are very common drilling tools in places from your home to a workshop, on the other hand, the impact drivers are a new kind of tool.
However, people are using them more and more day by day. Thereby, with both the tools making a benchmark, we often compare the two. Therefore, this will help you recognize the requirements of your project and choose the right tool for you, accordingly.
Why do we use them?
People often are confused about where to use them or which one to buy. In terms of comparison impact driver vs drill, they both are very efficient at drilling, driving, tightening and loosening screws, etc. Although they both hold advantages and disadvantages according to their own engineering. Mostly, it depends on where you’re using them. Their own structure works best for different situations and circumstances. For instance, heavy bolting is best done with impact drivers, on the other hand, a drill is an especially precise equipment.
What is an Impact Driver?
An impact driver is a progressive tool built for driving screws. Or otherwise, in laymen’s terms, it is a device that works on a battery and that drills holes and fastens nuts and bolts. Literally, if talking about impact driver vs drills, the former ones are preferred over other common drilling tools because they are fast and more powerful as compared to others. Nevertheless, another advantage is that they don’t take a keyless chuck and a collet is introduced which consists of hex-shanked driver bits.
Impact driver used for:
- Quick driving
- Powerful driving
- Removing screws and nails
Impact driver used when:
- Power is needed
- Stubborn screws will drive you crazy
- Your material is too thick
Consequently, like any other tool, the impact driver has its pros and cons
Here are some of the advantages of using an impact driver:
- Its size makes it manageable in every station.
- It’s very gentle in its removing process.
- Its immense power can penetrate through any hard and chunky material.
- It can work with any size, shape, and type of material.
- It is engineered in a way that doesn’t harm your arms or hands.
However, here are some things you might want to consider beforehand when taking impact driver vs drill decision:
- It’s not well suited for doing delicate work
- Precision is not its best feature
- As powerful and efficient as it is, it can be quiet costly
- It can be very loud for indoor projects.
- It only works on hex-shanked drivers
What’s a drill?
A drill is so common that everyone has one at home. Even if you don’t have one, you might remember seeing one somewhere on TV or in a creepy movie. In addition, they are also used to drive screws and nails. There are some factors that make up their value, like voltage. Furthermore, the variable voltage has a wide range of 8 to 60 V. you can control the size of the holes you drill by changing the voltage value. Additionally, they have a clutch that permits driving and drilling. Although some models also have a hammer function that helps in drilling holes in concretes and stones while using a carbide tip masonry bit.
Where do you use a drill?
- If you need to drive screws
- When you want to drill holes
- While you want to loosen or tighten bolts and screws
- Whenever the surface you are working on is very fragile
Here’s how a drill is better in some ways:
- It’s perfect for a small home or indoor projects
- Works so well when precision is needed
- Grip assist you in maintaining its power and direction
- Very friendly for a variety of screws
- Works great with other tools like rotary sanders
- Goes easy on the surfaces it is being used
Here are a few downsides to a drill:
- Although it is precise, however, it can often damage screws and nails
- It’s not exactly engineering according to the human body
- It can hurt your wrist.
Difference between an impact driver vs drill
Forthwith, let’s distinguish between the two tools further that is impact driver vs drill. On one hand, drills are all for accurate work. They can be used for a lot of other tasks and are somewhat bigger. Moreover, its handling helps you control how much force you want to exert and in what direction you want to exert it. As mentioned before, impact drivers, on the other hand, are much more powerful. They can be perfect if you don’t want to hurt yourself during using the tool.
Here are some basic differences between the two:
- When speaking of looks, an impact driver and a drill look very much alike. That is why it is hard to distinguish between the two just by looking at them.
- Even if the impact driver is stronger, it is actually smaller than a traditional drill. Impact drivers are also, usually, sturdy in design.
- The adjustable clutch on a drill lets the user work with constant torque. However, the impact drivers are unable to achieve constant torque. Also, an adjustable clutch protects the fasteners from being broken by the drilling action.
- Impact drivers deliver a greater force with more convenience. This automatically gives torque. So there are cordless impact drivers available in the market that have the option of three gears.
- The impact drills have a combo of a little bit of rotation and hard-hitting blows to drill/drive through the thick, hard, sturdy and concrete materials. You do not want to use a drill for that purpose. In other words, the impact drills can supply up to 2 to 3 times more power than a simple standard drill. The drill simply just rotates clockwise or anti-clockwise during its course of action. Some might require a hammer to work through.
- Impact drivers get the job done most of the time but the traditional drill still provides you with a safer option. It provides more comfort when it comes to the drilling and driving process.
Which one is the tool for easy use?
In terms of providing convenience, the impact driver definitely wins. They are very user-friendly and tools friendly as well. These machines work on a lot of screws and other tools. It delivers an immense amount of force making it very powerful and it also looks out after your body, keeping it away from harm. This is very efficient and suitable for big projects where strength is mandatory.
On the other hand, when we talk about a drill, it is not convenient when it comes to handling. Drills work better on clear cut projects. If you need your project to have more details, working with a drill might be a better option. However, it can injure your arm or hand if the drill gets caught in the material you are drilling into. It can loosen your grip or if you let go, it might start spinning and strike your hand.
Which one is a better tool?
Now that we have discussed both the tools in and out, impact driver vs drill, including their physical appearance, working, construction and handling, let’s now talk about which one is a better tool itself in general terms. Actually, both impact driver and a standard drill can be the perfect tool if used in the right project. If you use an impact driver for force, you will be satisfied with the outcome. And if you use a traditional drill for precision, you will get the precision done perfectly with efficiency.
What is the best choice for you?
If you need to work on drywalls, softwood, plastic or a fragile material in general, then you should choose the better option which is the drill. Since drills are not as powerful as impact drivers, they will not damage your material. They also do a very good job when it comes to removing screws and nails. You can multi-task with the drills.
So, in comparison impact driver vs drill, both have their own added merits and demerits. As is quite evident from the above discussion. So it can be concluded by saying that if you require an assertive force, then impact driver is great for that. Otherwise for precision works drills are the best choice.