New technology is yielding more powerful cordless outdoor power equipment and tools. So, what is an outer rotor brushless motor and how does it compare to inner rotor designs?
I spoke with Carlos Quintana, Senior Product Manager of Makita’s Cordless Tools division to get an idea of the difference along with the pros and cons of both designs.
- Inner rotor motors place the stator on the outside with the rotor on the inside
- Outer rotor motors place the stator on the inside with the rotor on the outside
- Inner rotor motors are longer with a smaller diameter
- Outer rotor motors are shorter with a larger diameter
- Outer rotor motors tend to be more efficient
- Most handheld power tools use inner rotor designs
General Design Differences
The main difference between inner rotor and outer rotor brushless motors lies in the basic design. All motors, brushed or brushless, use magnets to turn. The role of the stator is to provide a charge that will repel or attract the magnets and make the motor spin. The rotor contains those magnets and does the spinning.
On an inner rotor design, the stator is on the outside and the rotor is on the inside. On an outer rotor brushless motor, they flip.
Let’s say you have one of each type of motor with identical power outputs and overall diameters. How to do they look compared to each other?
They need the same magnetic surface area. Since the inner rotor design has the magnets against the inside, they’re on a smaller diameter – they will need to be longer.
The opposite is true on an outer rotor brushless motor. Attaching to a wider diameter means you can shorten the overall motor length. Also, you get a natural weight reduction.
Inner rotor motors also have an inherent wobble. They ride in and out slightly within the stator and lose efficiency. There are ways to deal with that, however. For example, Makita adds ridges to help stabilize their rotors and bring the efficiency up to 99%. But not all motor manufacturers do that.
Outer rotor brushless motors don’t have to deal with that movement and are inherently more efficient by design.
Balancing the Benefits
So you end up with two choices when you go with an outer rotor design. One option shrinks the length and weight of the motor to get the same power with a bump in efficiency.
Alternatively, you can maintain the weight and achieve more power with those efficiency gains. Of course, you can also find a balance between the two and shave some of the weight while increasing the power on a less substantial level.
The majority of brushless tools utilize an inner rotor design to cut down on overall size (girth). Makita currently uses four brushless inner rotor designs: 80mm, 54mm, 44mm, and 38mm.
The Makita 18V X2 string trimmer and their chainsaws get a fifth design with an 80mm outer rotor brushless motor. These larger tools have room to house the motor’s larger diameter while finding relief in the overall footprint since they have a narrower length.
That profile allows Makita to put the motors in those tools with a direct drive so they get the benefit of the most efficient power transfer.
Looking Forward to More Outer Rotor Brushless Motor Tools
As manufacturers look to drive more traditionally corded tools to cordless, you can expect to see more outer rotor brushless motors. Lithium-ion still hasn’t reached the pinnacle of its capabilities. Outer rotor designs will help generate more power and efficiency as we push the limits of what battery power can achieve.